Thursday, November 19, 2009

Speech Buddy Videos

The speech buddy videos were interesting this week. It was about education and school. It addresses the debate of homeschooling versus attending school. Dixie, who was in favor of home schooling talked about the advantages that come with home schooling. She used an ethos appeal when talking about Columbine to get the audience on her side. Robert, the other speaker, was talking about the disadvantages of home schooling and advantage of attending school. The children that are home schooled may be less social and more socially stunted. He raised questions about parents having to quit their jobs to home school their children. Robert also made the point that by going to school you are exposed to diverse people such as people from different races or religions and that being around people who are different from you will make you a more tolerant human being. Being sheltered is also a problem with home schooling. You won’t be as tolerant if you haven’t been exposed to different people and also you will be sheltered from the real world and hearing about violence and dealing with bullies. In real life, after home schooling, you are going to have to face bullies and violence so it’s not good to shelter children.

1 comment:

  1. I agree with you that the speech buddy videos were interesting this week. I really liked the samples of persuasive speeches given by Dixie and Robert. I like that you brought up the details about what was shown in the videos. Seeing samples of both the sides of the argument was interesting and useful. Dixie did talk about the advantages of home schooling and Robert made the point that by going to school you are exposed to diverse people such as people from different races, and that being sheltered is a problem with home schooling. I agree with his insightful perspective.

    ReplyDelete